The Librarians: The Next Chapter Season 1 Review

The two-part premiere of Librarians: The Next Chapter airs Sunday, May 25 and Monday, May 26 on TNT, before moving to Monday nights for the remainder of season 1.

Who would’ve guessed, back in 2004, that a cheeky little made-for-TV fantasy movie starring Noah Wyle would lead to multiple sequels, several tie-in novels and comics, and now two TNT series? Premiering 21 years after The Librarian: Quest for the Spear, The Librarians: The Next Chapter keeps the long-running franchise’s core formula intact: light adventure, a dash of magic, and a cast that knows exactly how seriously (or not) to take themselves.

By way of backstory, the Librarians of the title oversee an ancient repository for all manner of magical artifacts from throughout history, ensuring that nothing goes missing or ends up in the hands of potential world-beating baddies. Now joining their ranks: Callum McGowan as Vikram Chamberlain, a 19th-century Librarian stranded in the modern day thanks to a classic “Oops, the spell went sideways” mishap. As embodied by McGowan, Chamberlain is equal parts dashing, disoriented, and disarmingly earnest, all while looking like someone dusted off a character from The Prestige and dropped him into a basic cable show.

Vikram is joined by a capable new trio as he adjusts to life in the 21st century: Olivia Morris as a brainy mathematician who’s also a dead ringer for the ladylove he left in the past, Bluey Robinson as a YouTuber/conspiracy theorist who’s been waiting his whole life to be a part of something like this – and now can’t tell anyone about it! – and Jessica Green as a guardian who could probably punch through a wall if she needs to (and she usually needs to).

If you’re worried this new crew might drift too far afield from the franchise’s roots, rest easy: Christian Kane is on hand in the pilot, stepping back into the boots of fan favorite character Jacob Stone as if The Librarians never ended. It’s a shrewd bit of connective tissue and a quick assurance that, yes, this is still the same magic-tinged universe you remember. (Wyle doesn’t appear, but he is a producer here, so hope springs eternal for a guest spot by his character Flynn Carson.)

Stylistically, The Next Chapter is more throwback than reinvention. While earlier seasons of the previous series flirted with serialization, this one’s more monster-of-the-week – think Buffy the Vampire Slayer in its early years, or those comfort-food hours of Xena: Warrior Princess and Hercules: The Legendary Journeys from mid-’90s syndication. And that’s no accident: Dean Devlin, who’s been steering this ship since the beginning and serves showrunner duties here, knows better than to overthink a formula that already works.

McGowan makes a strong case for himself as the franchise’s new centerpiece, striking the tricky balance between swagger and sincerity. He’s got a bit of that James McAvoy glint – confident, a little broken, and always one sarcastic remark away from defusing a tense situation. The rest of the cast slots into their roles nicely, and it’s fun to watch them jell during the season’s early episodes – but the show knows whose name is on the library card, so to speak.

The Librarians: The Next Chapter isn’t trying to win Emmys. It’s TV with its sleeves rolled up – accessible, affable and proud to be what it is. In an era where genre programming often buckles under the weight of its mythology, there’s something refreshing about a series content to just spin capers with a magical MacGuffin, a plucky team, and the occasional demon. It might not set your social media feed afire, but it may well keep you coming back for a weekly dose of low-stakes, high-fun fantasy. And honestly? That’s a pretty good spell to cast.