An underrated marketplace for indie horror gems is Itch.io. Whether you’re looking for a good story to hook you or you want to feel alive through fear, here is our ranking of the 13 best horror games you can play right now on Itch.io.
The 13 best Itch.io horror games
13) NextDoor
13. Screenshot by Dot Esports Developer: Broelbrak Price: Free Scare rating: 4/10 Story rating: 4/10
As a huge fan of Junji Ito, I take no pleasure in saying there aren’t many great adaptations of this legendary horror mangaka’s work. However, a pixelated side-scrolling tribute of The Woman Next Door (from Mimi’s Tales of Terror), titled NextDoor offers just the right amount of horror you need in a compact setting. The idea of having a neighbor that never makes a sound even when they’re home all day is bizarrely unsettling, especially when you can see that multiple people live there. Paranoia sinks in as you start to believe something nefarious may be going on. Is the person behind the door even human?